Skip to main content
Phone Icon317-883-9790
  • Login IconLogin
    • Tenant Portal
    • Owner Portal
ES Property Management Logo
Facebook Instagram Linked In Youtube TikTok
    free management quote
  • Home
  • Services
      • Residential
        • Overview
        • Marketing
        • Tenant Screening
        • Rent Collection
        • Maintenance
        • Accounting
        • Eviction
      • Property Portfolio Management
      • Multi-Family Property Management
      • Commercial Property Management
      • Guarantees
      • Vacancy Loss Calculator
  • Investors
    • Investor Resources
    • Investor FAQs
  • Owners
    • Owner Resources
    • Owner FAQs
    • Owner Portal
  • Tenants
    • Tenant Resources
    • Tenant FAQs
    • Maintenance
    • Tenant Benefits Package
    • Tenant Selection Criteria
    • DIY Maintenance
    • Pet Screening
    • Tenant Portal
  • Agents
  • Homes for Rent
  • About
    • Our Company
    • Testimonials
    • Blog
    • Contact
    • Our Methodology
    • Our Team
MENU
ES Property Management Logo
317-883-9790
Owner Login Resident Login
  • Home
  • Services
      • Residential
        • Overview
        • Marketing
        • Tenant Screening
        • Rent Collection
        • Maintenance
        • Accounting
        • Eviction
      • Property Portfolio Management
      • Multi-Family Property Management
      • Commercial Property Management
      • Guarantees
      • Vacancy Loss Calculator
  • Investors
    • Investor Resources
    • Investor FAQs
  • Owners
    • Owner Resources
    • Owner FAQs
    • Owner Portal
  • Tenants
    • Tenant Resources
    • Tenant FAQs
    • Maintenance
    • Tenant Benefits Package
    • Tenant Selection Criteria
    • DIY Maintenance
    • Pet Screening
    • Tenant Portal
  • Agents
  • Homes for Rent
  • About
    • Our Company
    • Testimonials
    • Blog
    • Contact
    • Our Methodology
    • Our Team
Facebook Instagram Linked In Youtube TikTok
  • Sub Banner Image 1

Application Process and Tenant Selection Criteria

Learn about the ES Property Management application process and tenant selection criteria.

Resident Selection Criteria

What To Know Before Applying for a Rental Home

  • All adult applicants 18 and older must submit a fully completed, dated, and signed rental application and pay the application fee.
  • You will need to create a pet profile as part of your application. Please follow the directions on the application when asked to create your pet profile. Every applicant must do this, even if they are applying in a group and do not have a pet.
  • Shortly after paying for and submitting your application, you will receive a link to upload your income documentation to our third-party income verification service.
  • No rental property will be held vacant for more than two (2) weeks unless approved by ES Property Management.
  • Current occupancy standards are a maximum of 2 persons per bedroom, except for infants under 4 years of age.
  • Incomplete applications will not be processed.

Cost

If you decide to apply to rent one of our properties, there is a non-refundable application fee of $75 per adult that must be submitted with your application. Incomplete applications will not be processed.

The Application Process

Upon receipt of your rental application and application fee, we will:

  • Check your credit report
  • Check the public records for any past interactions with the eviction process
  • Verify your employment
  • Verify your previous rental history and references
  • Conduct a criminal background check
Resident Selection Criteria

Tenant Selection Criteria:

  • Our minimum credit score is 600.
  • Applicants must have a combined gross income of at least three (3) times the monthly rent. Incomes must be verified in writing, and applicants may provide recent pay stubs.
  • A minimum of two years of residential history is required. Rental history must be rated satisfactory or better, with no record of interactions with the eviction process. We reserve the right to require a higher security deposit.
  • Credit history and/or Civil Court Records must not contain rental judgments, eviction filings, rental collections, or liens, unpaid child support, more than 4 unpaid bills in collection, records of lease violations, and unpaid judgments to landlords.
  • If you have bad credit, bad rental history references, have been engaged in the eviction process, or have any felonies within the last 7 years for illegal manufacture or distribution of a controlled substance, felonies resulting in bodily harm or intentional damage or destruction of property (for example, “arson”), you will either be declined or may be required to post an additional security deposit as a part of your approval. In addition, Co-signers/Guarantors may be considered on an individual basis. Sexually related offenses for any time period will be declined.
  • A co-signer is required for all applicants who have a "No Credit" credit score.
Resident Selection Criteria

Security Deposit Determination

We use a risk-based deposit model.

The security deposit will never be less than one and a half months' rent. In some cases, we will ask for a higher deposit (up to 3 months' rent) depending on several factors detailed in our rental requirements.

Credit Score-Based Risk Mitigation Admin Fee

However, we can offer approval even to tenants with very low credit as long as they can pay the additional fee associated with their credit scores to offset the risk involved. If there are co-applicants, there is only one Risk Mitigation Fee per lease.

Risk Mitigation Admin Fees for Applicants:

Credit Score

Note: any credit score under any credit score under 600, (300-599) will be automatically declined due to bad credit. A cosigner cannot assist an applicant with a credit score below 600.

A co-signer can only assist if an applicant has no credit. However, a credit score above 600 does not automatically guarantee acceptance.

Resident Selection Criteria

Common Denied Lease Approvals

Note: This list is not exhaustive.

  • An incomplete application. Applicants will have one week to provide all documentation and information needed to process their application after submitting it. If there has been no communication during this week, the application will be denied.
  • Previous rental history reports from current/previous landlords that reflect too many late payments/NSF checks, lease violations, outstanding debt, or damage to the property can result in a denial.
  • No pets (with the exception of legally defined assistance or service animals) of any kind are permitted without knowledge and approval by ES Property Management.

The following pets will not be accepted under any circumstances:

  • Wolf Dog/Wolf Hybrids
  • German Shepherd
  • Doberman
  • Pitbull
  • Chow
  • Presa Canario
  • Akita
  • Mastiff/Bullmastiff
  • Caucasian Shepherd Dog
  • Cane Corso
  • Great Dane
  • Rottweiler
  • Belgian Shepherds (all types)
  • Or any mix of above breeds

Dogs in excess of 75 pounds will need owner approval. If a pet is authorized by ESPM, there will be an additional $500 added to your risk-based security deposit and a one-time $75 pet administrative fee per pet (max 2 pets).

Once Approved

  • Once you have been notified of your approval and you have chosen to accept your offer, you must send a written acceptance to us. You will then be sent a lease.
  • You must sign your lease and pay your Security Deposit and any Risk Mitigation Admin Fee, via certified funds, within 48 business hours of your approval notification. Once approved and these amounts paid, they are non-refundable.
  • In the event that you fail to enter into the lease agreement or refuse to take possession of the property on or before your approved move-in date, you shall forfeit these funds as liquidated damages.
  • The first month’s rent must also be paid via certified funds within 72 hours before your approved move-in date.
  • If an applicant applies for a property not yet ready for an in-person viewing, the applicant may waive viewing the property before applying. If an application accepts an offer prior to viewing the property, the applicant agrees the property is accepted “as is.”
  • Once a lease has been executed, the applicant waives the right to withdraw from the lease due to the failure of the applicant to view the property for any reason and assumes all risks associated with their failure to view the property.
ES Property Management Logo

We want to talk to you if you own one property or a hundred. We’re here for you if you’re planning a purchase, looking to sell, or needing help with property management in Indianapolis.

Contact Us Free Rental Analysis Employee Login

Contact

  • 3091 E. 98th St., Ste. 280 Indianapolis, IN 46280
  • T: 317-883-9790
  • F: 317.465.1601
  • indianapolispropertymanagement.com
  • ES Property Management
    3091 E. 98th St., Ste. 280 Indianapolis, IN 46280
    317-883-9790 david@indianapolispropertymanagement.com social sharing Indianapolis Property Management Property Management Indianapolis Property Management, Indianapolis investment services, Indianapolis Real Estate portfolio management, Indianapolis Houses and Homes for Rent

Owners

  • Owner Resources
  • Owner FAQs
  • Services
  • Owner Portal

Tenants

  • Tenant Resources
  • Tenant FAQs
  • Maintenance
  • Tenant Portal
Footer Affiliation Footer Affiliation 2020 Footer Affiliation 2022 Footer Affiliation 2023 Footer Affiliation 2024 Footer Affiliation top 10 Footer Affiliation narpm Footer Affiliation EHO Footer Affiliation Realtor Footer Affiliation MIBOR Footer Affiliation CIV Footer Affiliation EPA
  • Copyright 2025 ES Property Management. All Rights Reserved. Property Manager Website powered by PMW
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
ES Property Management is committed to ensuring that its website is accessible to people with disabilities. All the pages on our website will meet W3C WAI's Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.0, Level A conformance. Any issues should be reported to david@indianapolispropertymanagement.com. Website Accessibility Policy